Skip to main content
​Pre-Workout vs. Energy Drink: Which One Is Right for You?

​Pre-Workout vs. Energy Drink: Which One Is Right for You?

Posted by Leonard Shemtob on Jun 18, 2024

When it comes to boosting your energy and performance for a workout, two popular choices come to mind: pre-workout supplements and energy drinks. Both are designed to give you that extra push, but they work in different ways and offer unique benefits.

In this article, we'll explore the key differences between pre-workout supplements and energy drinks, their pros and cons, and help you decide which one might be the best option for your fitness goals. 

Whether you're hitting the gym, going for a run, or engaging in any physical activity, understanding these options will help you make an informed decision and maximize your performance.

[Related] Pre Workout Alternatives: Food VS Supplements


Short Summary

  • Purpose and Usage: Pre-workout supplements are specifically designed to enhance workout performance, while energy drinks provide a quick boost of energy for general activities.
  • Ingredients: Pre-workout supplements often contain ingredients like creatine, beta-alanine, and BCAAs, which target muscle performance, whereas energy drinks typically include caffeine, sugar, and B vitamins for a quick energy surge.
  • Benefits: Pre-workouts improve endurance, strength, and focus during exercise; energy drinks offer immediate energy and alertness but may lack workout-specific benefits.
  • Potential Drawbacks: Pre-workouts may cause side effects like jitters or digestive issues, and energy drinks often have high sugar content, which can result in crashes and other health concerns.
  • Finding Your Perfect Fit: We explore which option aligns best with your workout goals, whether it's sustained energy or maximizing your gym session.
  • Best for Workout Performance: If you aim to boost your workout performance, pre-workout supplements are highly recommended since they are specifically designed for this purpose.
  • Ready to enhance your performance? Start your journey with our top recommended pre-workout, Wild Thing, and experience the difference.


Understanding Pre-Workouts

Pre-workout supplements are specially designed products that help you enhance your exercise performance. They typically come in powdered form, which you mix with water and drink before your workout. 

These supplements usually contain a blend of ingredients that work together to give you the energy, focus, and endurance needed to maximize your workout.

Common Ingredients in Pre-Workouts

Caffeine: Known for its ability to increase alertness and reduce fatigue, caffeine is a key ingredient in most pre-workout supplements. It boosts energy and alertness, helping you stay focused and motivated.

Creatine: This compound is known for improving strength and power during high-intensity exercises. It helps your muscles produce energy quickly.

Beta-Alanine: Helps increase muscle carnosine levels, which can delay fatigue and improve high-intensity exercise performance.

Nitric Oxide Boosters: Ingredients like L-arginine and L-citrulline increase blood flow to your muscles, enhancing your performance and recovery.

Benefits of Pre-Workout Supplements

  • Increased Energy: The ingredients in pre-workout supplements work together to give you a significant energy boost, helping you power through even the hardest workouts.
  • Enhance Endurance: Improve your ability to sustain intense exercise over a longer period.
  • Improved Focus: Many pre-workouts contain ingredients that enhance mental clarity and focus, ensuring you stay concentrated and motivated throughout your exercise session.
  • Better Muscle Pumps: Ingredients like nitric oxide precursors increase blood flow to the muscles, providing you with better pumps and promoting muscle growth.
  • Boost Strength: Increase your strength and power to help you lift heavier weights easily and perform more reps.

Potential Side Effects and Drawbacks of Pre-Workout

  • Jitteriness: The high caffeine content in many pre-workouts can cause feelings of jitteriness or restlessness, especially if you are sensitive to stimulants.
  • Tingling Sensation: Beta-alanine, a common pre-workout ingredient, can cause a harmless tingling sensation throughout your body. It's usually temporary and nothing to worry about.
  • Digestive Issues: Some ingredients in pre-workout supplements can cause stomach discomfort, bloating, or diarrhea. This is especially common with high doses of certain amino acids and creatine.
  • Dehydration: Pre-workouts can sometimes make you sweat more, so it's crucial to stay well-hydrated before, during, and after your workout.
  • Increased Heart Rate: The stimulants in pre-workouts can raise your heart rate. This can be beneficial for energy but may be problematic if you have heart-related issues or are sensitive to stimulants.
  • Insomnia: Taking pre-workouts too close to bedtime can disrupt sleep due to their stimulating effects, primarily from caffeine.


Understanding Energy Drinks

Energy drinks are popular beverages designed to give you a quick boost of energy and increase alertness. They are widely used not only by athletes but also by students, professionals, and anyone needing a rapid-energy lift.

Common Ingredients in Energy Drinks

Caffeine: The primary ingredient, caffeine stimulates the central nervous system, reducing fatigue and increasing alertness.

Sugar: Numerous energy drinks contain high amounts of sugar, offering a quick source of energy.

Taurine: Believed to enhance athletic performance and reduce fatigue.

B-Vitamins: These vitamins help convert food into energy and support metabolic functions.

Herbal Extracts: Most energy drinks include ingredients like ginseng and guarana, which are natural stimulants believed to improve energy and focus.

Benefits of Energy Drinks

  • Immediate Energy Boost: Energy drinks provide a quick and noticeable increase in energy levels, making them ideal for a rapid pick-me-up.
  • Increased Alertness: The caffeine content helps improve focus, concentration, and mental clarity.
  • Improved Performance: Some people find that energy drinks help enhance their physical performance during short-term, high-intensity activities.

Potential Side Effects and Drawbacks

  • The Crash: The initial energy boost from caffeine can lead to a later crash, leaving you feeling tired and sluggish.
  • Jitters and Anxiety: Caffeine can cause jitters, restlessness, and anxiety, particularly in people sensitive to stimulants.
  • Dehydration: Energy drinks can cause dehydration if not properly hydrated.
  • Sleep Disturbances: Consuming energy drinks too close to bedtime can disrupt sleep patterns.
  • Limited Performance Benefits: While the caffeine might help you feel more alert, energy drinks don't offer the same muscle-building or endurance-enhancing ingredients found in pre-workouts.
  • Sugar Overload: Some energy drinks are loaded with sugar, which can lead to weight gain, blood sugar spikes and crashes, and even dental problems.
  • Health Risks: Excessive consumption of energy drinks has been linked to various health issues, including heart problems, high blood pressure, and sleep disturbances.
  • Caffeine Dependence: Regular use of energy drinks can lead to caffeine dependence, making it hard to function without them and leading to withdrawal symptoms like headaches and fatigue.


Pre-Workout vs. Energy Drink: Key Differences

We've explored the worlds of both pre-workout supplements and energy drinks. Now, let's compare them head-to-head to help you decide which one is the right fit for your pre-workout needs. 

Here's a breakdown of the key differences:

Purpose and Usage

  • Pre-Workout Supplements: These are specifically formulated to be taken before exercise to enhance performance. They are designed to provide sustained energy, focus, and endurance throughout your workout session.
  • Energy Drinks: Energy drinks are crafted to provide a quick boost of energy and alertness, typically for daily activities such as work, study, or as a pick-me-up during the day. They are not tailored specifically for exercise but can be consumed at any time when you need a rapid energy boost.

Ingredients

  • Pre-Workouts: Common ingredients in pre-workout supplements include beta-alanine, caffeine, creatine, and nitric oxide boosters.
  • Energy Drinks: Energy drinks often contain ingredients like caffeine, sugar, B vitamins, taurine, and herbal extracts such as ginseng or guarana.

Benefits

  • Pre-workout Supplements: Enhance endurance, strength, and focus during exercise, leading to improved performance and better results.
  • Energy Drinks: Offer immediate energy and increased alertness, making them suitable for quick energy boosts in various situations.

Timing of Consumption

  • Pre-workout Supplements: Taken 30 to 45 minutes before training to allow the ingredients to kick in and optimize performance during exercise.
  • Energy Drinks: Consumed whenever an energy boost is needed, regardless of whether it's before a workout, during work, or to combat fatigue.

Targeted Use

  • Pre-workout Supplements: Primarily aimed at individuals looking to maximize their workout performance and achieve fitness goals.
  • Energy Drinks: These are widely used by people seeking a quick energy boost for various activities, such as work, studying, or socializing.

In short, pre-workout supplements are geared towards optimizing your workout by providing targeted ingredients. Energy drinks offer a quick pick-me-up but lack the performance-enhancing benefits of pre-workout.


What is Better: A Pre-workout or Energy Drink?

When it comes to selecting between pre-workout supplements and energy drinks, the answer depends on your specific needs and goals.

Pre Workout

  • Targeted Performance Enhancement: Specifically designed to enhance workout performance by increasing endurance, strength, and focus.
  • Muscle-Specific Ingredients: Contains ingredients like creatine, beta-alanine, and BCAAs, which target muscle performance and energy production.
  • Endurance and Focus: Enhances muscle endurance, strength, and mental focus during exercise, allowing for better results.
  • Long-Term Fitness Goals: Supports long-term fitness goals by facilitating better muscle growth and development over time.

Energy Drink

  • Immediate Energy Boost: Provides a quick energy lift and increased alertness for various activities, not just workouts.
  • Convenience: Can be consumed whenever an immediate energy boost is needed, such as during work or study sessions.
  • General Energy Increase: Offers a temporary energy boost but may not provide the same targeted benefits for optimizing exercise performance.
  • Short-Term Solution: While effective for quick energy, it may not contribute as effectively to long-term fitness progress.

In conclusion, if you're looking to maximize your workout performance and achieve long-term fitness goals, pre-workout drinks are the better choice. However, for quick energy needs in various situations, energy drinks can be a convenient option.


Which is More Effective for Your Workout?

Pre-Workout Supplements: Designed with exercise in mind, pre-workout powders contain a carefully selected blend of ingredients such as caffeine, creatine, beta-alanine, and nitric oxide boosters to improve overall performance during your workout session.

Energy Drinks: While energy drinks can provide a quick energy boost, they are not specifically tailored for exercise. They often contain high levels of caffeine and sugar, which may provide a temporary energy surge but lack the targeted ingredients needed to optimize physical performance during a workout.

Sustained Energy and Focus

  • Pre-Workout Supplements: The effects of pre-workout supplements are typically longer-lasting, providing sustained energy and focus throughout your entire workout session.
  • Energy Drinks: Energy drinks offer a more immediate energy boost but may not sustain energy levels as effectively throughout a workout.

Improved Performance and Endurance

  • Pre-Workout Supplements: By enhancing energy levels, focus, and endurance, pre-workouts can help you perform at your best during exercise.
  • Energy Drinks: While energy drinks can provide a quick burst of energy, they lack the targeted ingredients to optimize physical performance.

Long-Term Fitness Goals

  • Pre-workout Supplements: Support long-term fitness goals by improving performance and facilitating better muscle growth and development over time.
  • Energy Drinks: While they can provide short-term energy, they may not contribute as effectively to long-term fitness progress.

The Verdict

Pre-workout formulas offer a clear advantage for those who want to take their workouts to the next level. Energy drinks can still be a helpful tool but for a different purpose. 

Maybe you need a pick-me-up before a casual jog or a long day at work. Just remember, they won't give you the same edge in the gym as a well-formulated pre-workout.


Exploring the Best Pre-Workout Supplements

1- Wild Thing by Assault Labs

Wild Thing by Assault Labs

Wild Thing contains a combination of amino acids, creatine, and other nutrients that may help fuel your muscles during exercise. Additionally, it includes various forms of caffeine, which can provide a boost of energy to power you through your workout. 

It includes various advanced nootropics to enhance focus, increase energy levels, and elevate your workout experience. Wild Thing also promotes vascularity and pumps, providing significant benefits to your workout routine. 

With a unique caffeine blend featuring patented ZumXR® & Infinergy® and two other forms of caffeine, this pre-workout powder offers an immediate energy boost and sustained fuel throughout your workout.

Key Benefits

  • It increases your energy levels.
  • It enhances your focus.
  • It improves your strength during workouts.
  • It boosts your muscle pumps.
  • It helps improve muscle endurance.
  • It promotes your overall mood.
  • It accelerates your muscle recovery.
  • It helps boost your cognitive function as well as overall workout performance.

Key Ingredients

  • DiCitrulline Malate/Infinergy®
  • Beta-Alanine
  • Alpha-Glyceryl Phosphoryl Choline
  • Agmatine Sulfate
  • Creatine Anhydrous
  • L¬-Glutamine
  • Choline Bitartrate
  • Caffeine Anhydrous
  • L¬-Tyrosine
  • L-Norvaline
  • ZumXR®
  • Huperzine A
  • Infinergy®
  • Cocoabuterol®
  • Thinkamine®

Customer Reviews

 Preworkout

“Great! I can feel the preworkout unlike other brands.”

-Brett B.


 Best Pump, great energy !

“The pump was great ! More vascular it’s on my arms! More energy since I train after work 1st shift. Worth the money ! I’ve tried tons of pre work out !”

-Zachary W.


 Amazing

“This pre workout provides an amazing pump would definitely buy again.”

-John G.


2- Seismic Surge by Hard Rock Supplements

Seismic Surge by Hard Rock Supplements

Hard Rock Supplements introduces Seismic Surge, a new pre-workout formula designed to meet the demands of elite fitness enthusiasts. Seismic Surge is designed for fitness enthusiasts who are looking to push their limits and achieve groundbreaking results. 

The supplement is engineered to capitalize on the latest breakthroughs in strength, stamina, and stimulant science to help individuals overcome plateaus and achieve their fitness goals. 

The supplement is said to provide a surge of energy that can help individuals power through their workouts and achieve a pumped-up physique. While individual results may vary, Seismic Surge may be a useful addition to a fitness regimen for those looking to enhance their workout performance.

Key Benefits

  • It helps boost energy levels.
  • It improves your muscle pumps.
  • It enhances your endurance.
  • It improves your mood.
  • It boosts your concentration and focus.
  • It increases your metabolism.
  • It helps enhance workout intensity.
  • It speeds up your muscle recovery.

Key Ingredients

  • Beta-Alanine
  • Caffeine Anhydrous
  • Alpha Yohimbine Hydrochloride
  • 1,3,7 Trimethylxanthine (Delayed Caffeine)
  • Theobromine
  • Gamma-Aminobutyric Acid
  • L-Citrulline Malate 2:1

Customer Reviews

 Excellent!

“If you're numb to pre-workout and you refuse to take a break from it, then give this one a try. Works very well.”

-T


 Very potent

“Strongest preworkout I have ever used including original craze and speed x2.”

-Dave


 Great

“Great product unlimited gas in the tank.”

-Sarge


3- Oracle by Olympus Labs

Oracle by Olympus Labs

Oracle is a truly innovative pre-workout supplement by Olympus Labs, featuring a powerful combination of ingredients, including genistein, a potent MAOI (monoamine oxidase inhibitor), and ligustrazine phosphate. 

This groundbreaking formula delivers transcendent levels of focus, endurance, pump, and energy, providing you with everything you need to conquer your next workout. The PR3 Tech in Oracle is designed to provide a balanced blend of key ingredients that can enhance both pre-anerobic and aerobic exercise. 

This blend is intended to help individuals achieve transcendent levels of performance in their workouts. The stimulant blend in Oracle is crafted to offer a sustained energy boost without causing a crash or jitters. 

This is achieved through a combination of ingredients that work together to provide a smooth and extended energy release. Oracle offers industry-best flavors, ensuring a pleasant experience with every sip.

Key Benefits

  • It enhances your exercise and sports performance.
  • It boosts your endurance.
  • It helps reduce fatigue.
  • It increases your strength.
  • It helps increase nitric oxide production.
  • It increases your energy levels.
  • It helps improve your mood and focus.
  • It promotes your overall productivity.

Key Ingredients

  • Ligustrazine Phosphate
  • S7™
  • Eria Jarensis Extract
  • Genistein
  • Enxtra®
  • Kannaease™
  • Xtenergy™
  • Infinergy™
  • Caffeine Anhydrous

Customer Reviews

 oh yea!

“very good, lots of energy, was able to do more reps on all my sets and felt great doing it too. recovery was quicker too and taste was light and nice. Im an oracle guy now lol”

-Richie M.


 amazing focus

“its a great product and focus is good during workout, just one thing keep yourself hydrated as it dries your throat a lot, but great endurance and focus good pump as well.”

-Abhishek


 Absolutely love

“This pre workout is absolutely amazing. It doesn’t give any jitters but gives you a boost to make you want to workout and enough energy to sustain a good workout. I love that I don’t get nauseated taking it. I have notice more endurance while doing CrossFit workouts as well.”

-Stephanie S.


4- Gorilla Mode Pre-Workout by Gorilla Mind

Gorilla Mode Pre Workout by Gorilla Mind

Gorilla Mode Pre Workout by Gorilla Mind is a scientifically designed supplement aimed at enhancing workout performance. The formula is designed to help individuals achieve peak physical potential by providing a potent blend of ingredients. 

The supplement contains high doses of effective ingredients that work together to enhance endurance, pumps, and energy. This formula is designed to help individuals take their workout performance to the next level.

Key Benefits

  • It increases your energy.
  • It elevates your motivation.
  • It enhances your muscle pump and vascularity.
  • It boosts your mental focus.
  • It enhances your endurance.

Key Ingredients

  • L-Citrulline
  • Creatine Monohydrate (micronized)
  • GlycerPump™ (65% Glycerol Powder)
  • Malic Acid
  • Betaine Anhydrous
  • L-Tyrosine
  • Agmatine Sulfate
  • Kanna (whole herb, Sceletium Tortuosum)
  • Caffeine Anhydrous
  • N-Phenethyl Dimethylamine Citrate
  • Bioperine® (black pepper fruit extract)
  • Huperzine A (Huperzia serrata leaf standardized extract)

Customer Reviews

 Amazing pumps

“On my 2nd jar of Gorilla Mode now and I've been loving the pumps and energy I get from it. I started with one scoop for the first few days then increased to 2 scoops. The difference from 1 to 2 scoops is very noticeable. Way more energy, way better pumps, and I felt a lot stronger during my training sessions. Love that it doesn't have any beta alanine because I personally hate the tingly sensation it causes.”

-Jason


5- Wrecked Pre-Workout by Huge Supplements

Wrecked Pre Workout by Huge Supplements

Wrecked is a pre-workout from Huge Supplements containing 17 ingredients. It aims to improve various aspects of your workout, including:

  • Strength
  • Focus
  • Muscle pumps
  • Performance

Wrecked Pre provides users with a substantial 30-gram serving, delivering significant energy, intense focus, extreme pumps, and enhanced performance during workouts. Users have reported notable increases in endurance, results, and overall physique.

Key Benefits

  • It increases your energy levels.
  • It enhances your focus.
  • It boosts your endurance.
  • It helps increase your pump.
  • It helps improve your strength.
  • It helps enhance physical performance.

Key Ingredients

  • L-Citrulline
  • Beta-Alanine
  • Betaine Anhydrous
  • S7
  • Theobromine
  • Agmatine Sulfate
  • L-Tyrosine
  • Hydromax
  • Alpha GPC
  • Eria Jarensis Extract
  • Lions Mane Mushroom Powder
  • Rauwolscine

Customer Reviews

 Insane pumps, energy, focus, and motivation!

“Started out with a heaping scoop to feel it out and holy moly... this stuff hits hard! Slowly working my way up to 2 scoops but even at 1 scoop this is by far one of the strongest preworkouts I've ever tried. Everything from the formula down to the flavoring ticks all the right boxes for me. Definitely my new favorite pre!”

-Jackson


FAQs: Pre-Workout vs Energy Drinks

Q: What is the difference between pre-workout supplements and energy drinks?

A: Pre-workout supplements are formulated to boost workout performance by providing a combination of ingredients like caffeine, beta-alanine, and creatine. Energy drinks, on the other hand, primarily focus on offering a quick energy boost through high doses of caffeine and sugar.

Q: Pre-workout vs. energy drink: Which one should I choose?

A: It depends on your goals. Pre-workout is ideal for maximizing your workout performance with a combination of ingredients. Energy drinks offer a temporary pick-me-up but may not significantly benefit your workout.

Q: Can I take a pre-workout and drink an energy drink together?

A: It's generally not recommended. Both pre-workout and energy drinks contain caffeine, and combining them can result in excessive caffeine intake, causing jitters, anxiety, and even heart palpitations.

Q: What are some of the best and healthy alternatives to energy drinks?

A: For a natural energy boost, consider green tea, which offers caffeine along with beneficial antioxidants. Fruits like bananas or apples provide readily available carbohydrates for energy.

Q: When is the best time to consume pre-workout supplements or energy drinks?

A: Pre-workout supplements are typically consumed 30 to 45 minutes before a workout, while energy drinks can be consumed whenever an immediate energy boost is needed, whether before a workout, during work, or to combat fatigue.

Q: Is pre-workout better than energy drinks?

A: It depends on your goals. Here's a quick breakdown:

  • For maximizing workout performance: Pre-workout wins! It has targeted ingredients to boost energy, focus, and muscle support.
  • For a quick pick-me-up: Energy drinks can work, but they lack the performance benefits of pre-workout.


Conclusion

In conclusion, the debate between pre-workout supplements and energy drinks ultimately boils down to individual needs and fitness goals. Pre-workout drinks are designed to optimize your workout performance. 

They pack ingredients like creatine and beta-alanine to help you push harder, lift heavier, and potentially recover faster.

Energy drinks, on the other hand, provide a temporary energy boost with a jolt of caffeine. They're great for a quick pick-me-up, but may not significantly benefit your workout itself. 

The choice depends on your goals. If you want to maximize your gym sessions, a well-formulated pre-workout can give you the edge you need. 

But if you just need a temporary alertness boost before a walk or jog, an energy drink (consumed responsibly) might suffice.


Sources:

https://www.boostcamp.app/blogs/pre-workout-vs-energy-drinks-which-is-better-1

https://www.garagegymreviews.com/pre-workout-vs-energy-drink

https://gymnation.com/blogs/pre-workout-vs-energy-drinks

Nehlig, A., Daval, J. L., & Debry, G. (1992). Caffeine and the central nervous system: mechanisms of action, biochemical, metabolic and psychostimulant effects. Brain research. Brain research reviews, 17(2), 139–170. 

Written and Sponsored by Leonard Shemtob

Leonard Shemtob is President of Strong Supplements. Leonard has been in the supplement space for over 20 years, specializing in fitness supplements and nutrition. Leonard appears on many podcasts, written over 100 articles about supplements and has studied nutrition, supplementation and bodybuilding. 

Leonard's articles have been published in many top publications around the web. Leonard enjoys weight training, playing basketball and yoga, and also enjoys hiking. In his free time he studies and works on improving himself. For more detailed information, visit his official blog.